KZN Cabinet report card: ‘Empty suit’ Premier fails to deliver, account

by Zwakele Mncwango, MPL - Leader of the DA in the KZN Legislature

Today’s annual KwaZulu-Natal Cabinet report card by the DA indicates an overall decline as an ‘empty suit’ Premier and 86% of his failing ANC Executive and their Departments record either no improvement or a regression in terms of performance levels.

According to the DA’s assessments:

  • The average score for the Executive was an ‘E”;
  • The Premier and his Acting Premier barely missed an ‘F’ – an indictment against the failing ANC leadership in this province;
  • A total of seven Departments regressed in terms of performance;
  • Those MECs who scored the worst marks and which showed no sign of improvement from last year are at the helm of some of KZN’s most critical service delivery Departments;
  • Six Departments remained the same as in 2017, showing no sign of improvement; and
  • Only two – the Office of the Speaker and Human Settlements, showed any improvements this year.

The reports are proof that governance in KZN has been relegated to a tick-box exercise by the failing ANC, which has forgotten its responsibility to the very people that elected them to these positions. Instead, what we have is a so-called leadership which is more interested in driving their own personal party agendas.

This untenable situation has been allowed by a Premier who has shown a lack of strong leadership or guidance and who has allowed ANC factionalism to have a devastating impact on the efficacy of the provincial government.

The Reports also highlight the lack of accountability within the KZN Legislature on various levels during 2018.

Notably, the Premier failed to hold his MECs to account for their lack of poor attendance at Sittings, TLTP’s, Hearings and portfolio committee meetings. Despite the fact that many MECs were absent more than they were present, the Premier does not seem to care and allows them to come and go as they please.

MECs also showed the same disrespect for the Auditor-General’s recommendations with less than 20% attending the Scopa Mid-term hearings into the finances of various Departments. With an attitude like this, the A-G’s announcement, just days ago, of an overall regression in provincial government departments’ finances during 2017/18, comes as little surprise.

Most significantly, the Premier has failed to hold his Health MEC, Sibongiseni Dhlomo and CoGTA MEC, Nomusa Dube-Ncube to account despite both having severely violated the rights of KZN’s people to proper service delivery.

Compounding Cabinet’s poor performance is the lack of urgency in responding to written parliamentary questions – a critical oversight tool for opposition parties. The Office of the Premier – which is supposed to lead by example – was one of the worst offenders, only replying to 33% of all DA questions. The worst offender however was Premier-in-Waiting, EDTEA MEC Sihle Zikalala who answered 32% of the DA’s questions.

Within his own Department, the Premier has also failed to address serious issues raised in forensic investigations within his own Department along with the Moerane Commission Report which is gathering dust on a forgotten shelf.

The irony of the Legislature slogan – a People Centred Activist Legislature – is not lost on the DA. Nor is it lost on the people of KZN. The failing ANC in this Legislature does not care about the people it is supposed to serve.

The failing ANC-leadership in this province has and continues to make a mockery of this Legislature. Critically, it has failed and continues to fail the people of KZN by not delivering on its mandate to improve and to address issues of the past through service delivery and job creation.

In 2019, the people of KZN have the power to bring about change when they go the ballot box. The kind of change that will release the true potential of our province and which will see the installation of a government that cares about the people and which will build One South Africa for All.


DA to petition Parliament to hold Bheki Cele accountable for Stanger 1.4% conviction rate


Democratic Alliance Media Statement by Dean Macpherson MP – DA ILembe Constituency Head

DA to petition Parliament to hold Bheki Cele accountable for Stanger 1.4% conviction rate

The Democratic Alliance (DA) will submit a petition to National Assembly Speaker, Baleka Mbete to hold Police Minister, Bheki Cele accountable for his steadfast refusal to address the crisis unfolding in Stanger after the DA revealed that the Police could only obtain a 1.4% conviction rate for murder, rape and robbery which was only beaten by the 0% conviction rate for hijacking in the last financial year.

It has now been 80 days since the DA requested the Police Minister to visit Stanger and address this failure by his police officers to protect the community. It has been more than two weeks since the DA marched with residents to the police station demanding Cele comes to Stanger, a request which he has arrogantly not acceded to.

This comes against the refusal of the Stanger Police Station to come to the rescue after a man was attacked on his farm and according to the man, the police station hung up four times after pleading for them to come to his rescue.

Eventually, a private security company arrested the attacker, handed him over the police station only for the attacker to be released a short while later.

It is becoming abundantly clear that the Minister, the police and the failing ANC simply don’t care about the criminal paradise that Stanger has become.

That is why we will now hold the Minister accountable through the Police Portfolio Committee and get to the bottom of why Minister Cele has such disdain for the people of Stanger as well as demand a turnaround plan from the Police including our request for the entire station management to be fired.

Communities such as Stanger require an honest, a professional and well-trained police service to protect them from criminals. What we see in Stanger today could not be further from this and the DA will not rest until heads roll.

DA saddened by the killing of a local businessman

Democratic Alliance media statement by Katheleen Naidoo, CLLR

DA Mandeni Councillor


DA saddened by the killing of a local businessman


The Democratic Alliance would like to send condolences to the family of the late Skyton Recycling owner at Mandeni Arnold Watkins who was brutally murdered last night. It is alleged that he was attacked at his home and shot with his own gun.


The high crime levels in Mandeni are a reflection of the whole country. Under the ANC government, South Africa is a dangerous place and our citizens are preyed upon on daily basis. Communities live in fear.

The DA is deeply saddened by this loss. Watkins was a longtime resident of Mandeni and was always willing to lend a helping hand to his community. The DA will be visiting the family to pay our last respect.

eThekwini Mayor blocks question on Fan Parks spending

Democratic Alliance media statement by Nicole Graham, CLLR

DA Ethekwini Caucus Leader


eThekwini Mayor blocks question on Fan Parks spending


The Democratic Alliance is deeply concerned about Mayor Zandile Gumede’s conduct in today’s eThekwini Executive Committee Meeting. After a presentation from Durban Tourism about the Soweto Derby Fan Parks at the weekend, which cost the city R3.6 million, a number of questions were asked by the DA.


The questions included a detailed request for the costs of the fan parks, particularly the beachfront venue which cost R3 million. We also requested details as to why the venues for the township fan parks had changed from what was agreed by the EXCO previously.


The company who approached the municipality for partnership reportedly called Comfort Fuze, doesn’t seem to have much online presence or track record. Company details were also requested by the DA.


Officials reported that Eyadini, one of the venues added on, made over a million rand on Derby Day. If this is the case, the DA questioned why they should be getting further municipal support.


The Mayor refused to allow officials to answer the questions, merely stating that she trusted them. She refused to allow DA Councillors to ask to follow up questions or get to the bottom of this matter.


Whilst the DA support the idea of the fan parks and encouraging tourism, there are too many unanswered questions about this item. Whilst the DA’s attempts at getting answers were thwarted by the Mayor, we will be following up with the municipal manager to ensure accountability.

DA asks Director of Prosecutions to investigate suspect withdrawal of intimidation case against ANC member

Democratic Alliance media statement by Zwakele Mncwango, MPL

DA KZN Premier Candidate


DA asks Director of Prosecutions to investigate suspect withdrawal of intimidation case against ANC member


The DA has written to KZN Provincial Director of Public Prosecutions, Adv. Moipone Noko, requesting that she investigates the suspicious circumstances that saw the withdrawal of charges of intimidation and firing a firearm by ANC member at DA councillors.

This shocking decision was apparently taken after what is claimed to be “problems” with the docket. The DA finds this unacceptable and is requesting the Provincial Director to look into what is clearly a miscarriage of justice.

Many cases have gone cold in this manner in our criminal justice system because of missing time. The DA will not let this case become another statistic.

On Friday a suspect was arrested based on the evidence given by the DA councillors after an incident of intimidation that happened last week where DA councillors were attacked during campaign activities in Kwanyuswa.

The DA suspect foul play and political interference in this case and is calling on prosecuting authorities to investigate.

It was disappointing to see ANC members who came out in numbers to support an ANC member who blocked councillors of the opposition party and even went as far as firing a firearm in a residential area, putting lives of many at risk.

The DA will continue to fight for a police and judicial system that is honest and professional, and will act to ensure the safety of all people regardless of political party affiliation.